ICEBlock creator sues Trump administration officials saying they pressured Apple to remove it from the app store
cnn_businessđ Article Content
ï»żICEBlock app creator Joshua Aaron issuingthe Trump administration, accusing it of abusing government power and infringing on his free speech bypushing Apple to remove ICEBlock fromits app store. Aaron argues thatICEBlockâ which was designed to allow users to alert others nearby about public sightings of Immigration and Customs Enforcement agents in their area â represents constitutionally protected speech, according to a complaint filed in Washington, DC, federal court on Monday. Aaron âbelieves that speech about publicly observed law and immigration enforcement activity â the expression enabled by ICEBlock â lies at the heart of the interests the First Amendment was intended to protect,â the complaint states. ICEBlock had more than 1 million users at the time of its removal, according to Aaron. Users who already had the app downloaded can still use it, but new downloads are blocked and Aaron told CNN he worries threats from administration officials may have discouraged existing users from using it. Apple removes ICE tracking apps after Trump administration says they threaten officers The suit names Attorney General Pam Bondi, as well as Homeland Security Secretary Kristi Noem, Acting ICE Director Todd Lyons, White House Border Czar Tom Homan and other, unnamed federal officials, as defendants. Representatives of the Department of Homeland Security and ICE did not immediately respond to CNNâs requests for comment. Apple did not immediately respond to a request for comment. A spokesperson for the Justice Department declined to comment, but pointed CNN to Bondiâs previous statements. âICEBlock is designed to put ICE agents at risk just for doing their jobs, and violence against law enforcement is an intolerable red line that cannot be crossed,â Bondi said in October. Aaron has repeatedly denied that ICEBlock puts agents at risk. âWhat I hope comes out of this is more of the public waking up to whatâs going on,â Aaron told CNN of his decision to file the suit. âI certainly hope that we set a precedent that they canât continue to quell and chill free speech. They canât continue to erode our constitutional rights.â The fight comes after Republican lawmakers have previously criticized andinvestigatedformer President Joe Bidenâs administration for what they said was inappropriately pressuring big tech companies to remove certain types of content. Aaron launched ICEBlock in early April amid President Donald Trumpâs immigration crackdown. He called the app an âearly warning systemâ for users when ICE is operating nearby, and has said it was designed to help people avoid contact with agents but not to interfere with their operations. When users log a sighting on the app, they see a notice saying: âPlease note that the use of this app is for information and notification purposes only. It is not to be used for the purposes of inciting violence or interfering with law enforcement.â He has likened ICEBlock to widely used map apps that allow users to crowdsource information about police speed traps. After CNN reported on the app inJune, Trump administration officials railed against the platform, claiming it put ICE agents at risk. Lyons released a statement criticizing CNNâs report and saying that ICEBlock âbasically paints a target on federal law enforcement officersâ backsâ and that âofficers and agents are already facing a 500% increase in assaults.â Bondi also told Fox News in June that Aaron should âwatch out, because thatâs not protected speech.â In October, Apple removed ICEBlock and similar apps from its app store, making them unavailable for download, following a request from the Justice Department. ICEBlock app creator Joshua Aaron responds to Apple yanking his controversial ICE tracking tool after pressure from the Trump administration. He tells Erin Burnett he fears he is now a target of the Trump Justice Department. Creator of âICEBlockâ app speaks out after Trump admin pressures Apple to pull app: âThey want to act in secrecyâ Apple told Aaron in an email that ICEBlock violated the app store guidelines and that it had received information from law enforcement suggesting the appâs âpurpose is to provide location information about law enforcement officers that can be used to harm such officers individually or as a group.â After Aaron responded to Apple saying ICEBlock had previously been approved for the app store, the company reiterated its note about having received information from law enforcement that the app put agents in harmâs way, the complaint states. Bondi confirmed the Justice Departmentâs role in the appâs removal in a statement at the time toFox News Digital, saying,âWe reached out to Apple today demanding they remove the ICEBlock app from their App Store â and Apple did so.â The app was only available on Appleâs iOS; Aaron previously said he would not be able to guarantee anonymity for users on Android. Aaron told CNN he hopes the lawsuit will uncover more information regarding communications between the company and administration officials. Aaron alleges that Bondiâs pressure on Apple to remove the app amounts to censorship by making ICEBlock âunavailable to the public,â according to the complaint. His complaint also states that threats from administration officials to investigate and criminally prosecute him over the creation of ICEBlock âwere intended and designed to chill Aaron and others from engaging in expressive activity â specifically, sharing information about publicly observable law-enforcement actions â and to deter technology companies and journalistic institutions from supporting, amplifying, or facilitating such speech.â The lawsuit seeks a declaration that what it describes as the governmentâs pressure on Apple and threats toward Aaron violated the First Amendment, and an order blocking similar statements going forward.